What you are about to see happened in March. And yes, I am ashamed it's taken me this long to post this. Sorry.
Remember the last
s'more sampler? It was so much fun that Elise and I decided to do it again, this time roping buddies Kylie (a s'more virgin) and Lucinda (a new s'more devotee) into the sugarfest.
The S'more Pop
Lisa's Rating: 8.5
Kylie's Rating: 10
Elise's Rating: 10
Lucinda's Rating: 10
Notes: For our first s'more, we decided to begin with the s'more version of an appetizer. I was the only one who didn't absolutely fall in love with these (the marshmallow to cracker ratio was a bit high in my opinion) but they were still pretty kickass, plus fun to make!
The Classic
Lisa's Rating: Who are we kidding? No need for individual ratings - we all gave it 10. It's classic for a reason.
Notes: Not needed.
The Lucinda Special
Lisa's Rating: 7.5
Kylie's Rating: 8.5
Elise's Rating: 8
Lucinda's Rating: 7.5
Notes: Lucinda was intrigued by our stunning failure of an attempt to create an alcoholic s'more (for those playing along at home, that would be The Flaming Captain Morgan S'more), and decided to try her hand at it. Instead of soaking or injecting the marshmallows with booze, she made a brandy chocolate spread. The brandy flavor was sweet and subtle, and the end result was pretty good!
The Coffee Bean
Lisa's Rating: 9
Kylie's Rating: abstained (not a coffee fan)
Elise's Rating: 9
Lucinda's Rating: 9
Notes: You can't see it, but inside each of those marshmallows are two chocolate covered coffee beans. The rest is a traditional s'more, although at the last minute (for reasons of Why The Hell Not?), we decided to swipe the marshmallows in Elise's chocolate fountain instead of using regular chocolate. The finished product was AWESOME. The only reason it didn't get a 10 from those of us who ate it was because the coffee flavor wasn't quite strong enough - we agreed that each marshmallow really needed three beans - but otherwise it was fab.
The More Bacon The Merrier
Lisa's Rating: 0.5
Kylie's Rating: 1
Elise's Rating: 2
Lucinda's Rating: 2
Notes: The bacon s'more we made at S'more-gasboard was so delicious that we decided to be really ballsy this time and take it one step further: replace the graham crackers with Sao crackers to make it more of a traditional bacon-and-cracker combo. The result was an almost inedible s'more. The others mustered up at least an entire skimpy point each solely on the basis that the s'more still contained chocolate ("And that must be a good thing. Right? Right???") but since I'm not much of a chocolate fiend, this didn't garner more than half a point from me. And I thought even THAT was generous. This s'more will haunt my nightmares. Blech.
The Peanut Butter Cup
Lisa's Rating: 7.5
Kylie's Rating: 8
Elise's Rating: 7
Lucinda's Rating: 8
Notes: Considering
my love of Reese's Peanut Butter Cups, I expected for this to be my winner of the day. But tasty as it was, something was off. Was it the thickness or texture of the cup? The peanut butter to chocolate ratio? I couldn't decide, and neither could anyone else - all we knew was that even though it was delicious, it just wasn't the amazing experience we were all hoping for.
By the way, if you ever set up a chocolate fountain outside, here's a pro tip: avoid the windy areas.
Elise's shed will never be the same again.