EDIT: Well I've received a few more replies, and so far the majority are ranting about my "pompous diatribe" and how I obviously "can't take a joke." Possibly it was a "pompous diatribe." However, I am alarmed that people would think the original email was
funny. Advocating the slaughter of immigrants is
not funny or amusing - if anything, it should be a huge wake up call, and I am sorry that our society has denigrated to the point that anyone could laugh at that idea. I also find it interesting that extremely few of the recipients considered MY replies funny (except for Amy - thanks for the comment!) and instead became highly defensive. Obviously, humor only works one way, and it's not the way of tolerance and reason. Also, if these people
really thought that any of this was funny...they wouldn't be getting so defensive.
* * * * *
I've received a ridiculous email about
Bill Cosby's fantasy political platform about fifteen times so far this election year. Tonight I became frustrated enough with the absurdity of the ideas to decide I'd had enough, and sent out my own belligerent reply to those folks "kind" enough to send the original to me.
* * * * *
If I get another of these emails, I may throw up my hands in surrender and become a Swiss citizen. So to save you the effort of sending these to me, here are my responses for the record:
I HAVE DECIDED TO BECOME A WRITE-IN CANDIDATE. HERE IS MY PLATFORM:
(1) 'Press 1 for English' is immediately banned. English is the official language; speak it or wait at the border until you can.
English is not the official language of the United States. I know that many people think it should be, but let's just remember for a moment that United States was founded by immigrants, for immigrants. The usual argument is that English should be the official language because most inhabitants born here speak it and have done so for a few centuries. But if you want to propose a national language based
purely on habitation claims, then logically you have to nominate an Native American language. It was spoken here long before English. But I'm guessing logic isn't playing much of a part in any of the items on this list.
(2) We will immediately go into a two year isolationist posture to straighten out the country's attitude. NO imports, no exports. We will use the 'Wal-Mart' policy, 'If we ain't got it, you don't need it.'
I actually burst out laughing when I read this. Really? No, really? Do you know where your clothes are made? Your food comes from? Your cars are built? (Hint: it's not the USA.) For that matter, do you know how expensive it is to buy solely American owned and made products? Go try it sometime. Do you really think for one second that the phenomenally spoiled American population, some of the greatest consumerists on the planet, would be happy paying $5 for an apple? (And wouldn't that just be the best thing for anyone in a low income bracket?) That's what will happen if you ban imports and exports: prices will skyrocket, because availability will decrease. This won't "straighten out the country's attitude," it will make the current crisis dive into a tailspin. It's not rocket science, it's basic economics.
(3) When imports are allowed, there will be a 100% import tax on it.
Sure. See above. Also, way to be wishy washy on your import/export stance!
(4) All retired military personnel will be required to man one of our many observation towers on the southern border. (six month tour) They will be under strict orders not to fire on SOUTHBOUND aliens.
For a country founded on immigration, I find it astonishing that so many Americans are so militant about illegal immigration. Yes, it's clearly a problem. Yes, it needs a solution. That solution is not to be found in violence. Do you know how difficult and incredibly expensive it is to immigrate legally? Really, go look it up. The solution is not to shoot people, it's to revamp the immigration system to allow people other than the wealthy (in other words, the people that really NEED to find hope and a better life in America) an easier path into the States. Why is it that the first instinct of so many Yankees is to hit someone in the head with a rock instead of offering a helping hand? 99% of your ancestors immigrated here, which makes you no better than anyone who is currently trying to immigrate, regardless of their country of origin, skin color, accent or legal status. Also, I'm sure all the retired military personnel will thank you for forcing them to move to the southern border, regardless of family ties or preference.
(5) Social security will immediately return to its original state. If you didn't put nuttin' in, you ain't gettin nuttin' out. The president nor any other politician will not be able to touch it.
Well I can tell you've done your research on this one. Of course, when it was originally created in the late 1930's, women and minorities were excluded from benefiting from Social Security. Roughly about half the working population were therefore exempt. And women only qualified for insurance through their husbands, while black families were assessed as needing less money than white families. Sounds like a sweet deal to me! Let's totally revert to the original state!
(6) Welfare - Checks will be handed out on Fridays at the end of the 40 hour school week and the successful completion of urinalysis and a passing grade.
So your proposed welfare restrictions will only apply to people attending school? Who wrote this list, a 15-yr-old?
(7) Professional Athletes --Steroids - The FIRST time you check positive you're banned for life.
This got my biggest eye roll ever. What the hell is an item about professional sports doing on a proposed political bill? In the current economic crisis, is this really a big enough issue to warrant inclusion on an election platform and garner votes? What kind of redneck does it take to put steroids on equal footing with immigration and economic issues?
(8) Crime - We will adopt the Turkish method, the first time you steal, you lose your right hand. There are no more life sentences. If convicted, you will be put to death by the same method you chose for your victim: gun, knife, strangulation, etc.
I find it amusing that the same people who cheer this list are the ones that solemnly nod when Biblically instructed to "turn the other cheek." Yes, some people are lost causes, but you need to acknowledge that there is a lot of failure in the cyclical nature of the current justice system. How about you put a little thought into how it could be reformed to help people instead of punishing them? I'm not advocating a total reversal and lack of punishments, but it's the old carrot vs. stick approach. (As a side note, this is an Islamic (sharia) law - and you know, dressing women in burkas would really help them not to be objectified and therefore lower sex crimes, too!)
(9) One export will be allowed: Wheat. The world needs to eat. A bushel of wheat will be the exact price of a barrel of oil.
Wheat? Really? Although the USA is the leading exporter of wheat, production has been declining for decades and it actually consists of a minor percentage of our exports. But I'm sure you totally knew that because you've done your homework on these issues, right? (For anyone who actually cares, you already know that capital goods make up nearly half our entire export income.) Way to give the ole economy a solid knee in the groin, Jim Bob! Manufacturing will die, farmers will go out of business, and major IT and medical companies will leave the US to set up overseas. Researchers would doubtlessly leave as well, since banning exports would also effectively ban major scientific projects that require international collaboration (which pretty much equals...all of them). What are you going to do? Forbid any US citizens to leave the country or do business overseas? That is one hell of a civil rights violation.
(10) All foreign aid using American taxpayer money will immediately cease and the saved money will pay off the national debt and ultimately lower taxes. When disasters occur around the world, we'll ask the American people if they want to donate to a disaster fund and each citizen can make the decision whether it's a worthy cause.
This is a great way to rebuild our international reputation. Really. It's also a great way to say thanks to other countries that gave the USA foreign aid after Sept 11. That's right, we received aid - the UK sent specialists with thermal imaging technology not available here. Canadians opened their hearts and homes to stranded families. Hell, even the French sent over specialized machinery to help with the excavations. But that's not really important, is it Cletus? Being the bully in the schoolyard is much more fun than playing with the other kids. (And in case you're wondering, yes, international reputation in a nuclear world matters. A lot.)
(11) The Pledge of Allegiance will be said every day at school and every day in Congress.
This is one of those pesky Freedom of Speech issues, kids. Yeah you could make it mandatory, but then you can make saying (or, perhaps more importantly,
not saying) just about anything mandatory. Your brain isn't an oversized paperweight - think this through a little.
(12) The National Anthem will be played at all appropriate ceremonies, sporting events, outings, etc.
See above. Damn that pesky First Amendment! It spoils EVERYTHING.
Sorry if I stepped on anyone's toes but a vote for me will get you better than what you have and better than what you're gonna get. Thanks for listening and remember to write in my name on the ballot in November. God Bless America !!!!!!!!!!! Bill Cosby!!!!!!!!
And about Bill Cosby - a quote from
snopes.com:
"We don't know who authored this reactionary "platform" for a write-in presidential candidate, but it was not (as a representative has confirmed) entertainer Bill Cosby. When Dr. Cosby speaks out politically, it is generally to urge blacks to take responsibility for making the most of education opportunities and eschewing choices that limit their potential for success. Immigration, imports, foreign aid, steroid use in sports, and insufficient recitation of the Pledge of Allegiance and the national anthem are not his political betes noires. (This "platform" has also been attributed to comedian George Carling, and it's equally out of tune with that late comedian's commonly expressed political views.)"
So let stop sullying Cosby's name with this ridiculous tripe, shall we?
* * * * *
So far, my only reply has been from an offended person telling me that the First Amendment applies to everyone, including those with views not in line with mine, but that "unfortunately civility is optional." I replied that is very true - that to encourage the idea of shooting people as they cross a border is, indeed, extraordinarily uncivil.
Look, I'm all for freedom of speech. I think that any idiot should be allowed to say whatever they want to say, without fear of repercussions. I really do. We're allowed to say and disagree with whatever we want, and that is a very precious freedom. But I also wish that people would just sit and
think for a moment before they start proclaiming what a good idea the things on this list are. The ideology of the United States is supposed to be one of tolerance, open minds and welcoming arms. How is it "American" to champion closing borders, killing immigrants, and stripping citizens of their First Amendment rights? Not to mention that I still have no idea what a line about steroid use is doing on someone's ideal political platform.
So. Am I just an uncivil hard ass?